In the heart of San Francisco, Father Joseph Illo, a devoted Catholic priest, recently penned an open letter to Pope Francis, expressing his deep concerns about the pontiff’s stance on homosexuality and its implications for his parish. In this letter, Father Illo candidly addresses the challenges he faces in his ministry, urging Pope Francis to preach the Gospel with clarity and conviction. Let’s delve into the details of this heartfelt plea.

Priest to Pope Francis: ‘You are hurting my parish’ by promoting homosexuality


Father Illo begins by setting the stage. He describes his parish as one in decline, located in a city that prides itself on its secularism and skepticism towards faith. In this challenging environment, his parishioners grapple with their beliefs, surrounded by a society that openly mocks and attacks their faith. Despite these trials, they hold fast to the core tenets of their faith, especially the Church’s teachings on the nature of the human person.

The Impact of Pope Francis’ Views

The crux of Father Illo’s concerns lies in Pope Francis’ promotion of homosexuality, which he believes has had a detrimental effect on his parish. He articulates his worries about the Pope’s mixed messages. While Pope Francis has acknowledged that two men cannot ‘marry’ and that homosexual acts are wrong, he has also encouraged bishops who bless same-sex unions. Father Illo contends that this ambiguity makes his pastoral duties extremely challenging.

Real-life Consequences

To illustrate the real-world consequences of the Pope’s stance, Father Illo shares poignant stories from his parish. He recounts the tragic journey of a woman who, after entering into a same-sex “marriage,” underwent transgender surgeries, ultimately grieving her mother. Another young woman from his parish, who ‘married’ another woman, underwent drastic surgeries to appear as a man and harbors resentment towards her Catholic upbringing. These cases, Father Illo asserts, are a direct result of the Pope’s permissive stance on homosexual unions.

A Plea for Clarity

Father Illo implores Pope Francis to consider the impact of his words and actions on faithful parishioners like the young woman who “points to you, Holy Father.” He reminds the Pope of his role as a spiritual father and urges him to teach the Gospel of Jesus Christ clearly, especially regarding the creation of humanity as male and female. Father Illo believes that such clarity is essential for effective evangelization and the well-being of the Church as a whole.

Pope Francis’ Controversial Stance

The article concludes by highlighting Pope Francis’ permissive approach to LGBT ideology throughout his papacy, which has often contradicted Catholic teaching on sexuality. This approach has led to confusion within the Church regarding LGBT issues. Despite the Vatican’s recent statement condemning same-sex ‘blessings’ as illicit, Pope Francis has continued to endorse same-sex civil unions, further challenging the Church’s traditional stance.

In closing, Father Joseph Illo’s open letter to Pope Francis highlights the genuine concerns of a parish priest facing the repercussions of the Pope’s stance on homosexuality. It serves as a call for clarity, conviction, and unwavering adherence to Catholic teachings in addressing this complex and divisive issue within the Church.

SHARE this Post with a Friend!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *